We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
1-888-987-9474
9AM - 6PM EST Monday - Friday
Have Questions? See our FAQs sectionOr use our Contact Us form
Carrot Cake
54.00
"The cake was delicious. My boyfriend and his family loved it. Thank you so much !!! "
Golden Fudge Southern-Style Cake
56.00
Strawberry Funfetti Cake
"We loved the cake it taste amazing and looked exactly as it was pictured. MH "
Gluten-Free Red Velvet Cake
60.00
"This was a complete shock! I loved it. The box, the design the taste- everything!"
Blossoming Rose Cake
55.00
"Arrived on time and was packed beautifully! I send these cakes to my mom, and she and her friends love them! They freeze 12 to enjoy later and each time they've thawed it, the cake was just as delicious and fresh as when it was first shipped. Always a big hit!!"
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
53.00
"This cake was sent for a birthday. They raved about it and said it was delicious. In fact, they plan to use Bake Me a Wish in the future. "
Vanilla Bean Cake
52.00
"Happy customer the cake was delivered on time and tasted great would definitely recommend or use bake me a wish again."
Chocolate Truffle Cake
"Arrived on time to my friend who is going through a hard time in her life. She said it was beautiful and delicous!! "
Chocolate Chip Coffee Cake
45.00
Boston Cream Cake
"The cake is so light and fluffy that it truly melts in your melt. My crusty, old curmudgeon of a husband loved it and he hates everything.And the customer service, as always, made me feel like a rock star."
Caramel Apple Cake
"Great cake, customer service started well although I am still waiting for a credit to my account 5-7 days.......more to follow"
Lemon Coconut Cake
"Delivered on time to Sefona,AZ in perfect condition while it was over 100 degrees. The freshness and flavor was excellent. I also added cookie and brownie sample packs. Very good also. "
Chocolate Mousse Torte Cake
"The cake arrived on time. The celebrant expressed a very good review, he said it is very delicious not too sweet and the cake is moist. He said it is one of the best chocolate mouse torte cake!"
Cookies and Cream Brownie Cake
48.00
"Arrived on time, and my girlfriend thought the cake was good! -"
Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie Cake
"awesome service. will probably purchase again! its perfect for surprises"
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
"It was sent for a birthday gift. They loved the cake. They said it came in a beautiful tin and was very good tasting!"
Classic Cake Sampler
"The recipient of the gift raved about it. I will be sending it to someone else very soon."
Limoncello Cake
"Third year in a row weve got this same Limoncallo Birthday cake. Its so good even though we love chocolate we cant even make ourselves try another one. "
Gluten-Free Vanilla Cake
"Happy that you could provide buttercream icing. Product was excellent. Delivery was on time and with care by UPS."
Tiramisu Classico Cake
"Great cake and service. "
Lemon Poppy Coffee Cake
31.50$45.00SALE!
"Fabulous coffee cake with a light lemon flavor and delicious poppy seeds. My new favorite!"
Classic Confetti Cake
"Tasty, pretty cake. Fresh. Delivered as scheduled. "
The Freedom Cake
84.00
"Absolutely Outstanding! Such a beautiful delicious surprise! Bake Me A Wish is the BEST! Customer Service is superb as well! Soldiers deserve a special treat too ..God Bless"
Tres Leches Cake
"La entrega se realiz sin retrasos. La presentacin encant muchsimo y de sabor, me dijeron que estaba rica fue un regalo, no la prob. Lo nico negativo es el tamao pens que seria ms grande. Debera especificarse el peso del pastel en la descripcin."
Black and White Mousse Cake
"Arrived on time. Cake was moist and delicious. "
Rainbow Cake
58.00
"My granddaughter absolutely loved it. "
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
"amazing cake!! It was delicious!"
Blackout Cake
"First time about 12 people have ever tasted a Blackout Cake, they were amazed with how delicious it is. The cake came on time and thawed out perfectly for a surprise birthday!"
Flourless Chocolate Cake
"It was easy to order, arrived at my daughter's apartment on schedule, and tasted delicious. I would highly recommend Bake Me a Wish to anyone wanting to surprise someone or just have a delicious cake!"
German Chocolate Cake
"Delicious, moist and rich. Perfect size for our get together. "
Gluten-Free Chocolate Truffle Lava Cakes
50.00
"TOTALLY amazed my daughter-in-law who is gluten allergic. The whole family enjoyed these mouth watering cakes with vanilla ice cream. My DIL can now enjoy cake again!! YAY! Fabulously presented, packaged and delivered too."
Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Cake
"Outstanding GF choice. Comparable to local choices when on sale or shipping is reduced. "
Red Velvet Chocolate Cake
"I was told that the cake arrived packaged with care and that the cake looked elegant and was moist"
Coconut Cream Cake
"Excellent Cake. I love the coconut cream, with real whipped cream between the layers. Light and tasty. Have ordered this cake several times and as gifts for friends and family. "