We won’t send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time.
1-888-987-9474
9AM - 6PM EST Monday - Friday
Have Questions? See our FAQs sectionOr use our Contact Us form
Blackout Cake
52.00
"The birthday boy was very happy with the cake! Thanks for all your help. "
Tres Leches Cake
54.00
"Exactly what I needed for a birthday cake! Tasted great! Delivered on time and packed so it stayed cold!Couldn't ask for anything better!"
Gluten-Free Double Chocolate Cake
60.00
"My daughter reported that this cake was spectacular!Thank You for providing me with an opportunity to participate in her 'special birthday'!"
Black and White Mousse Cake
"Arrived on time and in great condition. Shipping costs may make me reconsider ordering any more cake"
Strawberry Funfetti Cake
"Buy this cake! It is now our family's favourite. "
Salted Caramel Chocolate Cake
53.00
"Thank you so much for making a birthday surprise successful! It was on-time and looked beautiful in the pictures. I've never tasted one of your cakes but they look super. I'll be using your service over and over again!"
Gluten-Free Red Velvet Cake
"Fantastic! Beautiful! Punctual!! Wishes came true!"
Coconut Cream Cake
"Sent it as a birthday gift. It arrived as promised. Looked good and the receipient said it is yummy"
Chocolate Chip Coffee Cake
45.00
Lemon Poppy Coffee Cake
"Fabulous coffee cake with a light lemon flavor and delicious poppy seeds. My new favorite!"
Flourless Chocolate Cake
58.00
"Sent bday gift to my GF nephew who was traveling for bday, staying at Airbnb. Not only was delivery spot on cake simply perfect! What surprise to have yummy GF cake with candles too surprise! Bakemewish helped make special occasion over the top for super special person! Not 1st purchase def not last!! Ty for delectable GF cake & making memorable occasion!! "
Carrot Cake
"I loved it! Shipping was on time and the taste was amazing. "
Tiramisu Classico Cake
"I sent this cake to a friend of mine and they said it tasted great. It arrived on the date promised too. The cake arrived in pretty good condition, just one of the dollops of icing was out of place. Other than that the cake was a hit."
Lemon Coconut Cake
"The cake was delicious. Fresh and the way that they packed the cake was great. I was worry about UPS delivery it arrive at 500 PM. "
Classic Cake Sampler
48.00
"Arrived on time. Perfect birthday surprise! "
Classic Confetti Cake
"We sent this to our grandniece for her first birthday. Everyone loved it. I've sent several before and they have always been a big hit."
Vanilla Bean Cake
"AMAZING! Arrived timely, packaged well, thawed perfectly, absolutely delicious! Well worth the price. My friends and I loved it!"
Rainbow Cake
"It was delivered on the day it was promised to my granddaughters for their third birthday. And they said it was absolutely divine. I would highly recommend this cake and Company"
Red Velvet Chocolate Cake
"I received my cake on time! Happy about that! It was packaged safely and the ice pack was still frozen! The cake tasted really good and the icing was delicious. It was fresh & moist. I think next time I will order a larger size but it was perfect for my occasion. Comes in a cute box."
Caramel Apple Cake
"Easy to navigate online to.plave an order.. I ordered a cake for my mom's 80th birthday. It came in a beautiful box with a matching card. It made a great presentation. My mom loved it. Will order again!"
Boston Cream Cake
"This was a gift for my high school Art teachers birthday. The delivery was perfect. She was very excited when she called me! She had not been able to find her favorite Boston Cream Cake pie. She absolutely loved the packaging, the card and most of all the cake. Thank you so much for assisting me with sending one of my favorite people in the world a big fat BD hug. Too brief a treat !"
Chocolate Mousse Torte Cake
"Perfect delivery. Perfect cake thank you "
Cinnamon Coffee Cake
"This is the most amazing, delicious Coffee Cake I could recommend. It is absolutely perfect."
Golden Fudge Southern-Style Cake
56.00
The Freedom Cake
84.00
"Absolutely Outstanding! Such a beautiful delicious surprise! Bake Me A Wish is the BEST! Customer Service is superb as well! Soldiers deserve a special treat too ..God Bless"
Chocolate Truffle Cake
55.00
"Delivery was prompt on date requested. Tracking was clear and concise. The cake was delicious as feedback by receiver. The best thing is that the cake is delivered without damage although it has to be transported across states. Well done!!!"
Cookies and Cream Cheesecake
"Sent as a gift to a friend who loved every bite!"
Gluten-Free Vanilla Cake
"Good looking and tasted great"
German Chocolate Cake
"Lovely Gift packaging and delicious taste! A real winner."
Gluten-Free Chocolate Truffle Lava Cakes
50.00
"recipient loves the lava cakes best he has had"
Blossoming Rose Cake
"was delivered on the exact day specified and was still frozen. looked and tasted amazing. the icing was still picture perfect. loved it!!!!!!"
Cookies and Cream Brownie Cake
"I sent this cake to my niece for her birthday. She said one of the best cakes shes ever had AND she was not sharing with her roommates. "
Limoncello Cake
"Sent this to my parents for their anniversary and they absolutely loved it! "
Triple Chocolate Enrobed Brownie Cake
" My son loved his cake! Would order this one again."