We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. Please read our Privacy statement for more information.
Bake Me A Wish!
Loyalty Reward Program
$1 spent = 1 point

It's easy! You earn 1 point for ever $1.00 spent. For more info, see your Loyalty Program dashboard.
5 Dollars Off Reward Icon
100 Points
10 Dollars Off Reward Icon
250 Points
15 Dollars Off Reward Icon
500 Points
20 Dollars Off Reward Icon
800 Points

Gifting has never been more exciting with our Rewards Program and we’ve just taken the savings to a whole new level! Introducing our VIP REWARDS: for a fresh way to save even more on your next gift purchase.
We’re making it even easier to earn those Wish Points!


Your total earned wish points are now calculated into a special savings tier, as seen in the chart below. When you have enough wish points, you’ll automatically be enrolled into the first VIP tier and receive 1.5x the points for every purchase! You can earn up to 2.5x wish points for every dollar you spend.

More Wish Points = More Rewards

For birthdays and more, it’s easy to send them what they’re wishing for!

DISCLAIMER: Loyalty points can be earned through qualifying purchases on www.bakemeawish.com, exclusive of shipping fees. Every $1 spent = 1 loyalty point. Points can then be redeemed for loyalty rewards as stated on www.bakemeawish.com/loyalty.php. Only one loyalty reward can be redeemed per purchase. Once used, a reward will not be returned at any point, even if the purchase is cancelled/refunded for any reason. A loyalty reward code cannot be combined with a promotion code. Points cannot be redeemed for cash and cannot be traded, transferred, copied, bought, sold or bartered. Points do not expire. Bake Me A Wish! reserves the right to modify program rules at any point. Bake Me A Wish! reserves the right to cancel or suspend this program at any time. Not applicable to corporate clients or wholesale partners.


What is Loyalty Program?

Loyalty Program is our customer membership program, which entitle our members to special rewards and perks.

How do I join Loyalty Program?

You simply create an account here. When you arrive at your dashboard you will see "View my Loyalty Rewards" tab. This is your rewards program dashboard.

Is there a fee to join Loyalty Program?

No, it's entirely complimentary! You simply have to create an online account at www.bakemeawish.com to be eligible to join Loyalty Program.

How do I earn Loyalty points?

It's easy! You earn 1 point for ever $1.00 spent. For more info, see your Loyalty Program dashboard.

Do my Loyalty points expire?

No, Loyalty points do not expire.

I think I'm missing points from previous purchases.

Our Loyalty Program was launched on July 29th, 2017. Any orders placed prior to launch were not counted toward redeemable points as the program did not exist. However, based on recent previous purchases, you may have received the corresponding points.

Can I opt out of emails?

Yes, you can unsubscribe from receiving marketing communications by clicking the "unsubscribe" link at the bottom of our emails. That link will take you to a page where you can opt out of marketing emails from Bake Me a Wish. You will no longer receive special offers from us. You cannot opt out of receiving order/shipping confirmation emails.

Do I receive a membership card?

No, everything is digital. We like trees.

How can I view my account summary?

Every quarter you will be emailed an account summary. In addition, you can log into Loyalty Program dashboard and see your points and rewards history.

What happens when I want a refund on a product purchased with points?

Any approved return of a product purchased with points, either in isolation or in combination with other payment methods will cause the original payment methods to be refunded. Such refund shall be proportionately distributed across the original payment methods in the event that it is a partial refund.

How do I become a VIP?

It's Simple! Start making purchases on our website to earn 1 point per dollar. We also offer non-purchase methods to earn point ssuch as referring a friend or leaving a review. You automatically become a VIP after 500 points.

When will I earn the next tier?

Check your personal rewards page for VIP thresholds and your current point level. You can view your rewards page after you log in.

What do I get for becoming a rewards memeber?

In addition to earning increased points, you'll be put on a special list for each tier that allow you to access exclusive features such as paying for Gifts with Points, Shipping for Pionts and much, much, more!